Ask the Trainer Q & A

Personal Trainers  //  We get dozens of questions each week. There is more Q & A on the Following Page:

Personal Trainer Questions

If you have read the website and haven't found the answers you are looking for, fill out the following contact form with your question.

Ask the Personal Trainer a Question

For expert guidance and a fitness program tailored to your specific goals make sure to check out:

Online Personal Training

Mar 13 / 11:37pm

Drop 2 Jeans SIzes

QUESTION:
Hello, I'm a 5'6" 167 pound female who would like to go down 2 pants sizes.  My pre baby weight 12 years ago was 132lbs while in shape. I now have 2 kids and 35 extra lbs lingering... I gained 73lbs with my first pregnancy and lost about 40 before I got pregnant again with my 2nd child.

It has now been 9 years and I am desperate. I've tried everything in the book, you name it. I am 31 years old 5'6" and 167 lbs.looking to losing about 20lbs in my midsection and buttocks.

I am very frustrated that I have been working out and dieting for 8 years and I can't drop below a 9 in jeans. I exercise twice a day everyday but Tuesdays, I work cardio during the day for an hour and I just recently started the p90x lean In the evening. 

I understand everyone says throw the scale out, numbers mean nothing. Its about how you feel and how your clothes fit. Well I am one of those people that just have strong legs and the first place I gain.. I eat a healthy 950 calorie low fat, no sugar, healthy carb, diet...

For some reason can't figure out the reason I can't get down in my pant size. Can you help?

ANSWER:

I would first like to say that a 950 calorie diet is far too low for you, especially while working out twice a day almost every day. Your body is in a starvation mode right now causing it to hold onto the fat you have left, because you are literally starving your body even thought it may not feel like it. If you are performing two workouts a day, then you are burning almost as many calories as you consume in a day!

I would recommend that you increase your calories, possibly to around 1,200 divided into 5-6 evenly spaced meals. I think it would also be best to limit your workouts to one time per day for a while. You have to try to reset your body so to speak.

Your thyroid hormones which control your metabolism are probably not functioning so well right now. If you find that you still cannot lose weight after following this advice, I suggest that you visit an endocrinologist to determine whether or not your hormones are off balance. I wish you the best. Feel free to ask any more questions any time!

 DavidFrankovic.AskTheTrainer.com

Filed under  //  diet   nutrition   weight loss  

Comments (0)

Feb 22 / 6:33pm

Want a Flat Stomach

QUESTION:
Hello There. I am 5"3 and weigh between 115-120 pounds. I am a normal size, small, teen. Even though I am not big, my stomach always bulges out after I eat. I want to have a flat stomach like other girls. I was hoping you could help me by giving me some exercises i could do to help. Also, that would be nice if you could give me some tips on the types of foods I should be eating for the process. Thank you very much.
ANSWER:
First of all, even though your physical dimensions look to be completely normal you should determine your body fat percentage.  Knowing this will help you determine whether or not you would benefit from losing a couple pounds of stored fat and/or put on a couple pounds of lean muscle to make your body more toned.

Another thing to consider is your posture.  If you have lordosis (an excessive lower back curve) your stomach will appear to protrude which will appear bulged rather than the flat look you like.  You may need to work on your posture with a combination of resistance training and stretching.  Read about Muscle Imbalances and Posture Problems

Lastly you may have food allergies you do not know about.  There are many common food allergies such as wheat gluten, lactose, et cetera which often go undiagnosed for years.  They are often not serious but the undesirable effects on people can be very annoying.

An effective way to determine whether or not you have food allergies is to simply start a nutrition journal.  Note how you feel after eating certain foods to narrow down the foods that cause your stomach to "bulge out."  This will help you control food choices better as well as balance your diet with adequate amounts of all nutrients especially fiber, protein and water intake.
You can also find similar questions and answers on this blog or on the following page:

Filed under  //  muscle toning   tone   toned body   toning   weight loss  

Comments (0)

Jan 26 / 7:00pm

Lose Weight While Improving Legs

QUESTION:

I am 45 yrs of age and trained many years with a wealth of knowledge when it comes to exercise. My problem is I want to increase leg size, this has always been a problem, crap legs runs in the family so I don't expect miracles. At the same time I need to lose approx 20-25lbs body fat which is proving to be a nightmare now that I am older. I do my weights, and then cardio on none weight training days, which includes bag work and jump rope amongst other things, but nothing changes.  My concern is that if I receive help with losing some body fat my legs will shrink to nothing, Can I lose some body fat and still improve my legs?

Exercises for my legs vary in order every 8 weeks, leg ext squat, leg press, leg curl, stiff leg dead lift & some times roman chair squat. Reps very 5X5 or 6-8 10-12 15-20 every 8 weeks and at present I train 3x week back-chest rest legs -shoulders rest biceps-triceps, after 8 weeks I will change to perhaps chest-biceps legs on there own rest shoulders-triceps, then back on its own and rest. There are many combinations I use each 8 week period and this always keeps things interesting. I have tried all sorts 10x10 gvt gironda 8x8 and 6x6 standard methods super sets and trisets. Many thanks for your time.

ANSWER:

It is definitely possible to maintain size in your muscles while you lose weight (fat).  There are a few reasons why people often lose a significant amount of muscle during a weight loss program.  Out of all the reasons the one you should be worried about is insufficient calorie/protein intake in relation to the amount of protein catabolism in the system. During weight loss there will be less anabolic hormones and available energy for reparation of muscles after training.

Just as you cannot eat the same way when trying to lose weight that you were eating when you were trying to put it on, you simply just cannot train the same way as when you were trying to build mass as you're dieting to lose weight.  Your lifting routine, specifically your leg routine sounds pretty comprehensive.  It is recommended you dramatically lower your weight training volume while you lower your caloric intake and increase your cardiovascular activity to burn.

Since weight training has become in vogue over the past 10 years people are beginning to get the wrong idea that weight training is the best thing for fat loss as well as building muscle.  Weight training is solely a stimulus for your body that depends completely on your diet.  If you weight train too much and don't consume enough calories it will have negative effects on your body including fatigue and loss of muscle mass.

Your goal with weight training is simply maintenance your current muscle mass.  You can minimize losing your leg mass by performing shorter duration workouts.  You do not need more than 3-6 sets of exercises for muscle group to maintain muscle.  In fact numerous studies have shown that a single set of weight training can be just as effective.  Including High Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) in your cardio program as opposed to mostly marathon style workouts will also help.  If you properly replenish your energy after HIIT workouts you are less likely to lose muscle mass as opposed to long duration workouts which are more likely to use your body protein as fuel.

Last but not least, your diet needs to stay balanced.  Eating 4-6 small meals per day, each containing adequate protein, carbohydrate and fat will help keep your insulin levels stable throughout the day.  You will be less likely to overeat, hindering your weight loss and you will be less likely to crash during a workout.  You may want to check out these combination exercises which will lessen your time in the weight room, work the full body quicker so you can concentrate on your calorie incinerating cardio.

Filed under  //  leg muscles   weight loss  

Comments (0)

Jan 19 / 9:12pm

Fat Roll under Breast

QUESTION:

After two kids I gained quite a bit of weight, I have (over the last year) lost most of it. I am working out at the gym to tone up. I have like I guess a roll right uder my breast.. What exercises can I do to get rid of it?

ANSWER:

It sounds like your excess body fat is being stored upper abdomen which is very common.  Most people misunderstand fat distribution.  Depending on your genetic fat distribution but most people have "problem areas" which are the areas which their genetics determines where they store the majority of the fat.  This does not mean there is still not excess fat stored around the rest of your body.

By "working out in the gym" you've taken a step in the right direction.  There is no specific exercise you can do to spot-reduce fat you just simply need to perform your cardio 3-5x per week and eat a healthy diet.  If you really want to ramp up the intensity to speed up results, you can perform combination exercises which work multiple muscle groups.

Filed under  //  fat loss   muscle toning   weight loss  

Comments (1)

Jan 17 / 8:19pm

Recumbent Bike Reduce Cellulite

QUESTION:

Hello, I'm a 5'8" tall 180 pound woman.  Will recumbent exercise bikes help tone and reduce cellulite in legs?

ANSWER:

That is a very general question and the very general answer is:  Yes!  Is a recumbent bike better than a treadmill, stairmaster, a track or eating less calories?  No.  Cellulite is a by-product of having excess body fat for most people.  Your dimensions would indicate your body fat percentage is high.  You can check the page about Body Fat Percentage in Women to learn more about it.

A cardio exercise program which can include a recumbent bike will burn calories based on the time and effort you put into your exercise sessions.  It is up to you to eat less calories (food energy) than you burn to provide a stimulus for your body to burn fat as fuel.  Once you lower your body fat to a healthy percentage then cellulite will be reduced.  If you're asking whether exercising on a recumbent bike will magically lessen cellulite in your legs at your current dimensions the answer is no.  You have to lose weight first.

Filed under  //  cardio equipment   cellulite   fitness equipment   gym equipment   weight loss  

Comments (0)

Nov 7 / 8:07am

Weight Loss No Time for Exercise

QUESTION:

Hello, I'm a 6 foot 270 pound guy who wants to lose weight and tone.  I want to lose weight but I don't have a lot of time to work out. I want to take a supplement. Should I take protein shakes?  What else can I do?

ANSWER:

The two most important things you can do for weight loss are cardiovascular exercise and eating the right types of foods.  The goal is to get your body into a caloric defecit. 

In general, you should aim to do a bare minumum of 30 minutes of cardio at least 3 times a week.  The more cardio you can do, the better.  As far as nutrition goes, aim for eating a variety of lean meats, fruits, veggies, and healthy fats. 

Protein shakes are a fine addition as long as they do not contain large amounts of sugar, saturated fats, or calories.  Specific recommendations about a cardio routine and a nutritional plan vary from person to person and depend on a number of variables. 

Hope this helps and best of luck to you!

MattHines.AskTheTrainer.com

Filed under  //  exercise   weight loss  

Comments (1)

Oct 28 / 11:18pm

Get Lean Maintain

QUESTION:

I am a 19 year old female who weighs 66kg at 165cm and am about 30% body fat I think. I started lifting 3kg dumbells and doing dumbbell squats about a year ago. I would do this usually for about 3 weeks then give up and stop for anywhere between a week to a month then I would start again. It got to a point I was doing 14 reps (3 sets) and everytime I would stop/start I could still do 14 and every time I did this (particularly the first time) I would see results within a week and become slimmer within 3-4 weeks every time.

I have started again about a week and a half ago after a roughly 4 week break and I am not seeing results this time. (though right now, I am probably the fattest I have been in over a year) I have figured I probably need to increase resistance, but I don't want to continue increasing the weight I lift for the rest of my life.

My question is: Let's say, hypothetically, I lift heavier weights for a while and achieve a slim body I am happy with, do I need to keep increasing resistance/building muscle, changing my routine and all that just to MAINTAIN the figure I have? Could I just keep doing the same amount of reps at the same weight 3-4 times a week to maintain a good figure?

I would be able to commit to this long-term, but I want to maintain muscle mass rather than continue to build it, and I obviously do not want to gain weight. I also don't wish to increase my cardio (I walk fast for an hour to an hour and a half a day and it seemed to have worked in the past). Exercise machines are out of the question, I very much enjoy walking.

Sorry about such a long question but any help is very much appreciated! I couldn't find the answer to this anywhere on the internet.

ANSWER:

To answer your main question, yes you most certainly can get to the point where doing the same weights and volumes of exercise can maintain you at a particular conditioning level. You generally increase certain aspects of your exercise such as weights and sets to improve yourself towards your personal goals but once you reach a point that you prefer to stay at, stopping the increases and keeping them at that level is indeed the way that you can maintain.

I will advise you though that taking such long breaks every few weeks like you've been doing will easily slow your progress towards your goals and may even prevent you from getting all the way to them. You are repeatedly allowing your body too much of an opportunity to forget what you are putting it through, and it is very likely to regress during those times that you are again completely inactive.

I hope this was helpful Lauren. please feel free to check me out at my site so that i may assist you with any future concerns you might have. http://jasonspencer.askthetrainer.com Go ahead and read all about what i can offer you! Hope to hear from you.

JasonSpencer.AskTheTrainer.com

Filed under  //  toning   weight loss  

Comments (0)

Oct 28 / 10:57pm

Cardio Twice a Day

QUESTION:

I'm looking to lose weight and have a question concerning cardio. I normally workout in the am but have found myself going at night at times as well to do more cardio. I realize this may not even be doing me any good? Can your body only burn so many calories anyway??

ANSWER:

Doing cardio twice a day the way you described is not necessarily hurting you or doing anything detrimental to your health and training, although it can... It all depends on how many days you are doing this and what you are doing during the workouts. Of course if you are working out intensely each time and doing two a day, you are much more likely to overtrain yourself, hurt yourself, get sick, etc....

But if you aren't going twice a day often at all or aren't really doing anything that is too strenuous, this habit is really just unnecessary and inefficient for you as opposed to dangerous... There is no reason to ever have to do two sessions at separate times in a day if you are organizing your activity effectively enough and in a way that provides great energy expenditure.

And actually, the very fact that you have the energy to go back and do another workout later at night often times means that the first one did not push you the way it should have. So although it doesn't necessarily hurt you for reasons i've explained, two a day workouts are almost never necessary.

It is much more efficient and beneficial to you to perform one great workout and then rest to let your body respond to it! There are many many great ways to maximize the effectiveness of your workouts to make sure they do for you what you want...

I hope this was helpful to you! Please feel free to check me out at my site and read all about me and what I can offer you in assistance with any other concerns you may have. http://jasonspencer.askthetrainer.com I hope to hear from you!

JasonSpencer.AskTheTrainer.com

Filed under  //  cardio   cardio frequency   weight loss  

Comments (0)

Oct 28 / 10:37pm

Sagging Skin

QUESTION:

Hello, I'm a 5'9" 200lb. woman and have no idea what my body fat percentage is.  I have lost 40lbs in the past two months and plan on losing another 60+ lbs. Already I have sagging skin.

I am 22 years old and don't smoke. Are there any targeting exercises I can to get rid of this sagging? How long on average will it take to pop back? Will it pop back? Will I need cosmetic surgery?

ANSWER:

Just let me say first off congradulations on the weight loss so far! But now you have the problem of loose skin I see. When someone loses a good amount of weight, alot of times it comes off faster than what the body can do to keep up with it. So the body's adjustment to the decrease in size and fat loss in various areas of the body, lags behind creating the loose sagging skin.

Fortunately, this does not mean that the skin's plasticity will not come back to a large extent... Furthermore what you can do to help the process is to tone and firm up the musculature underneath the skin to kind of fill out the space left by the fat loss a bit more. So Angela when we're talking about weight training and muscle toning there is such thing as targeting and there are definitely exercises you can do to improve specific areas. The right organization of what exercises, when, and how you do them will most certainly get you to where you want to be.

Please feel free to check out my site just to read all about me and get an idea of anything else I can help you with. I hope this was helpful and that I may be able to assist you again in the future! Hope to hear back from you!

Filed under  //  loose skin   sagging skin   weight loss  

Comments (0)

Oct 28 / 10:13pm

Body Not Losing Inches

QUESTION:

Why I seem to lose weight around my waist and stomach but the rest of my body seem to have the same measurements?

ANSWER:

The most likely reason that you could be losing the weight more around your midsection than anywhere else is because you may just have more to lose in that area, and don't have as much body fat as you think in those other areas... There is no such thing as spot reduction.

Meaning that when you lose weight and body fat, the body does not lose it in just one specific area. It takes fat from all areas where there is significant amounts of body fat with no particular preference. So if you are not seeing a decrease in measurements of the other areas, there must not be as much fat in those places.

The other possibility is that you are losing significant fat in those areas but depending on how much strength training you are doing, the added muscle tone is just offsetting the decrease in body fat and causing the size to remain despite the fat loss...

I hope this has been helpful! Please feel free to check me out on my site and read about me and anything i can offer you in regards to any future concerns you may have. Hope to hear from you!

JasonSpencer.AskTheTrainer.com

Filed under  //  body composition   toning   weight loss  

Comments (0)