Ask the Trainer Q & A

Personal Trainers  //  We get dozens of questions each week. There is more Q & A on the Following Page:

Personal Trainer Questions

If you have read the website and haven't found the answers you are looking for, fill out the following contact form with your question.

Ask the Personal Trainer a Question

For expert guidance and a fitness program tailored to your specific goals make sure to check out:

Online Personal Training

Mar 16 / 9:13pm

Shoulder Workout Post Rotator Cuff Injury

QUESTION:
Hello, I'm a 5'7" 162 pound guy who wants to build muscle and strength.  I'm recently comming off a rotator cuff injury and started seriously training again.

I noticed dramatic strength loss in my shoulders and want to be very careful not to re-injure it. Every now and then I feel a little "tweak" pain but nothing major. I found your website and it's very knowledgeable.

I would like to try a shoulder workout. My question is would I try the "best shoulder workout" or the " most effective shoulder workout" I would imagine it would be the "best shoulder workout" but I just want to make sure?

ANSWER:
Shoulders are one of the most debilitating types of injuries for all forms of human movement especially building muscle with resistance training.  The chances for recurrence are high as well so you should be very careful. 

The Best Shoulder Workout or Effective Shoulder Exercises pages as you mentioned are really there for general ideas.  By no means is there one shoulder workout which is the absolute best.  I know I mention somewhere that unless you have 100% healthy shoulders, you should not perform intensive shoulder workouts and may even want to avoid shoulder exercises altogether.  At the very least make sure you do not perform any shoulder workout earlier than 48 hours, preferably more following a chest workout as the muscle groups overlap.

Since all upper body exercises and even most lower body exercises require shoulder stabilization or movement it is essential you work to bringing your shoulders to 100%  You can accomplish this by a variety of means.  Most importantly, make sure your exercise form is biomechanically correct for each exercise you do.  Even your static posture has a lot to do with whether your rotator cuff will heal properly or cause problems in the future.

If you haven't please read about the anatomy of the rotator cuff and the exercises you can do to strengthen the small muscles which it's composed of.  Make sure to check out "The Rotator" which is a product which is used extensively by the pros to maintain rotator cuff health and flexibility.

Comments (0)

Mar 13 / 11:37pm

Drop 2 Jeans SIzes

QUESTION:
Hello, I'm a 5'6" 167 pound female who would like to go down 2 pants sizes.  My pre baby weight 12 years ago was 132lbs while in shape. I now have 2 kids and 35 extra lbs lingering... I gained 73lbs with my first pregnancy and lost about 40 before I got pregnant again with my 2nd child.

It has now been 9 years and I am desperate. I've tried everything in the book, you name it. I am 31 years old 5'6" and 167 lbs.looking to losing about 20lbs in my midsection and buttocks.

I am very frustrated that I have been working out and dieting for 8 years and I can't drop below a 9 in jeans. I exercise twice a day everyday but Tuesdays, I work cardio during the day for an hour and I just recently started the p90x lean In the evening. 

I understand everyone says throw the scale out, numbers mean nothing. Its about how you feel and how your clothes fit. Well I am one of those people that just have strong legs and the first place I gain.. I eat a healthy 950 calorie low fat, no sugar, healthy carb, diet...

For some reason can't figure out the reason I can't get down in my pant size. Can you help?

ANSWER:

I would first like to say that a 950 calorie diet is far too low for you, especially while working out twice a day almost every day. Your body is in a starvation mode right now causing it to hold onto the fat you have left, because you are literally starving your body even thought it may not feel like it. If you are performing two workouts a day, then you are burning almost as many calories as you consume in a day!

I would recommend that you increase your calories, possibly to around 1,200 divided into 5-6 evenly spaced meals. I think it would also be best to limit your workouts to one time per day for a while. You have to try to reset your body so to speak.

Your thyroid hormones which control your metabolism are probably not functioning so well right now. If you find that you still cannot lose weight after following this advice, I suggest that you visit an endocrinologist to determine whether or not your hormones are off balance. I wish you the best. Feel free to ask any more questions any time!

 DavidFrankovic.AskTheTrainer.com

Filed under  //  diet   nutrition   weight loss  

Comments (0)

Mar 13 / 11:08pm

Exhausted 13 Year Old Son

QUESTION:
My son is 13 years old and is currently doing winter training for paddling, specifically kayaking. He is working out 4 times a week. We are wondering what he should be eating to maintain this level of exercise?  We have been finding that by midweek that he is feeling really exhausted and run down - so much so that the cannot attend school.  Please Advise.
ANSWER:
Your son is feeling run down towards the middle of the week, because he is simple not eating enough calories to recover from the strenuous kayak sessions. I would start by suggesting that you make sure he is getting plenty of protein sources in his diet such as chicken, lean beef and fish. Protein is very important because it will help your son's muscles recover from those hard workouts, so he can continue to train hard.

Since his kayak sessions are probably long and hard, his calorie needs are probably much higher than a normal sedentary child at his age. Simply eating more good wholesome foods that are protein rich might solve the problem here, but I have a feeling he might not be a big eater. If he isn't then it might not be a bad idea to look for ways to add calories to his meals. Some easy ways of going about this are adding cheese to a dish or adding a glass of milk juice, but it wouldn't be a bad idea to let him have some pizza and cheeseburgers every now and then.

If he needs more calories, but isn't willing to eat much more, then tasty calorie dense foods would work. Just be sure not to go overboard. It might be best to allow him to have those foods after his kayak sessions. Thank you for your question, and please feel free to ask any more that you may have!

 DavidFrankovic.AskTheTrainer.com

 

Comments (0)

Mar 6 / 5:35pm

Total Gym vs. Ironmaster Super Bench

QUESTION:
I'm 5'5" tall, weigh 190 pounds and am about 30% body fat.  My goal is to tone.  I am thinking about buying a total gym or a weight bench, specifically the superbench by ironmaster. Which one is better?
ANSWER:
Both are great pieces of equipment and viable options for a home workout.  The Ironmaster Super Bench is a multi-purpose weight bench which requires dumbbells and other equipment to get a full body workout.  The Total Gym can give you a full body workout with no added equipment with few necessary upgrades. 

You can find the Ironmaster Super Bench Combo on Amazon along with a set of adjustable dumbbells for $699 USD or the bench alone for $289 but keep in mind you will be paying for all the attachments which make the Ironmaster Super Bench a versatile piece of equipment.  The Total Gym models vary in price.

Since both pieces of equipment are good, consider price first.  Do you already have a full set of dumbells and/or barbells to use with the bench?  If not, that is going to cost more than the cost of the bench itself.  Dumbbell free weight exercises tend to have a tougher learning curve than Total Gym cable exercises if you're a beginner.  Also keep in mind that the Total Gym can be used as a standard weight bench for dumbbell exercises as well.

Most importantly consider which machine will help you achieve your goals most efficiently.  At your current physical dimensions, the Total Gym is going to allow you to start off with a small percentage of your body weight. As you make progress you can simply move the platform up a notch to use more of your body weight.  Your goal is not to build maximal strength which is the only real weakness of the Total Gym as it's better for muscular endurance.

Personally I would get the Total Gym if price is not an issue and you do not already have dumbbells.  If you already have dumbbells I would probably get the Ironmaster Super Bench  I would probably not get the because dumbbells are available at every gym in existence which is often the natural progression for people who get in shape at home with their own equipment and you can't find the Total Gym or machines like it at most gyms. 

These 2 Links May Help you Decide:

Filed under  //  exercise equipment   fitness equipment   gym equipment   total gym  

Comments (0)

Feb 25 / 11:58am

Concerned about Heart Rate During Exercise

QUESTION:
Hello, I'm a 5'6" woman who weighs 154 pounds with 26% body fat.  I would like to lose 20 pounds.  I have been working out for the past 6 months. I focus on running (currently up to 3 miles a day) and light weights.

I am concerned about my heart rate. When I began working out my average heart rate was about 165. My recent average heart rate is 180. It sometimes gets as high as 180 even by just doing simple sit ups and does not begin to decrease until about an hour after my work out. Do you have any suggestions?

ANSWER:

First of all, you should have consulted with your physician before you started exercising.  If not, do so before you continue to exercise.

Your heart rate during exercise will depend primarily on your resting heart rate.  Resting heart rate increases with age which was not mentioned in your question.  First thing you should do is take your resting heart rate.  This is best done first thing in the morning after you wake up. 

Take your pulse for 10 seconds and multiply it by 6 or take it for 30 seconds and multiply by 2, etc. to determine your resting heart rate.  Then use this formula to determine an estimate of your max heart rate:

HRmax = 206.3 − (0.711 × age)  Once you have your resting heart rate you can use the Karvonen formula to determine your target heart rate.

Karvonen method

The Karvonen method factors in Resting Heart Rate (HRrest) to calculate Target Heart Rate (THR), using a range of 50%–85%:
THR = ((HRmax − HRrest) × %Intensity) + HRrest
Example for someone with a HRmax of 180 and a HRrest of 70:
50% intensity: ((180 − 70) × 0.50) + 70 = 125 bpm
85% intensity: ((180 − 70) × 0.85) + 70 = 163 bpm

If the average heart rate of 180 is way out of the 85% intensity zone then you may have an issue of some kind which a doctor will be able to answer.  You also mention your heart rate is elevated for doing resistance training exercises.  This may be due to poor breathing during your exercises. 

Do not hold your breath during muscular contractions.  If you are doing light weights and high reps, you should keep your breathing rate normal at around 12-20 breaths per minute, rather than hyperventilating.  On a side note you are likely wasting your time with weight training exercises performed in sets over 20 is a waste of time but that is off subject...

If you have no physical problems, your elevated heart rate is likely a result of simply low fitness levels in which a consistent progressive routine will help.

  

Comments (0)

Feb 22 / 6:33pm

Want a Flat Stomach

QUESTION:
Hello There. I am 5"3 and weigh between 115-120 pounds. I am a normal size, small, teen. Even though I am not big, my stomach always bulges out after I eat. I want to have a flat stomach like other girls. I was hoping you could help me by giving me some exercises i could do to help. Also, that would be nice if you could give me some tips on the types of foods I should be eating for the process. Thank you very much.
ANSWER:
First of all, even though your physical dimensions look to be completely normal you should determine your body fat percentage.  Knowing this will help you determine whether or not you would benefit from losing a couple pounds of stored fat and/or put on a couple pounds of lean muscle to make your body more toned.

Another thing to consider is your posture.  If you have lordosis (an excessive lower back curve) your stomach will appear to protrude which will appear bulged rather than the flat look you like.  You may need to work on your posture with a combination of resistance training and stretching.  Read about Muscle Imbalances and Posture Problems

Lastly you may have food allergies you do not know about.  There are many common food allergies such as wheat gluten, lactose, et cetera which often go undiagnosed for years.  They are often not serious but the undesirable effects on people can be very annoying.

An effective way to determine whether or not you have food allergies is to simply start a nutrition journal.  Note how you feel after eating certain foods to narrow down the foods that cause your stomach to "bulge out."  This will help you control food choices better as well as balance your diet with adequate amounts of all nutrients especially fiber, protein and water intake.
You can also find similar questions and answers on this blog or on the following page:

Filed under  //  muscle toning   tone   toned body   toning   weight loss  

Comments (0)

Feb 17 / 11:07am

AFAA Personal Trainer Certification

QUESTION:
I am currently enrolled in a AFAA cert. workshop, and I am concerned due to that association not being listed as one of the top certs. for Personal Training. Is AFAA a reputible association? Will I find good employment? And would it benefit me to have a more prestigious Cert.? Which one would be the best one to get at a resonable cost? Help...

ANSWER:
First and foremost you should have contacted your (prospective) employer first to see which certifications they accept.  If AFAA is one of the certifications they recognize there is no difference whatsoever between personal trainer certifications.  Most clients do not care which certification their trainers have and most don't have a clue about personal trainer certifications.

While some gyms require specific certs, most recognize the vast majority of certifications and AFAA is in that group. If you're just starting out as a personal trainer, which it sounds like you are, the AFAA is 99% likely to get you a job.  Other more "prestigious" personal trainer certifications are only that because they've either been around longer or spend millions of dollars marketing themselves.

Be like a sponge and soak up all the knowledge you can in your 3 day workshop.  By the time you, pass your test, get a job, start training clients, and build your clientele it will be time for you to get continuing education (CEUs or CECs) to retain your certification.  The best way to get continuing education is to obtain another certification. 

It will not only likely (along with CPR re-certification) satisfy your continuing education requirements for your AFAA certification, but give you another certification so after 2 years you will have a wealth of experience, 2 certifications and you can expand your business. 

This is pretty much how it goes for most people who stick with personal training.  It usually takes a year or 2 working in a large corporate gym before most personal trainers are able to expand their business by moving to a more profitable location, opening up their own business or expanding their services.  As far as other, more "prestigious" certifications it really depends on what your specialty will be.  Coming from a BS and MS in exercise science, the NASM training philosophies have changed the way I train clients and helped me the most so I would recommend give the NASM a try when time for your second certification rolls around.

If you haven't found a place to work yet, or simply want to do everything the right way it would be beneficial to go through the follow guide I've created.

Comments (0)

Feb 16 / 7:35pm

Lose 35 Pounds in 3 Months

QUESTION:
I am a 5'5" 160 pound 16 year old girl who is tired of her parents complaining about how fat I am and that I need to lose weight. I agree I am obese and I am trying to lose as much as I can. Is it possible to lose 35 pounds in 3 months or less? Will it have any side affects like flabby skin? How can i lose 35 pounds in 3months under the stress of school? Tips?
ANSWER:
It is unlikely you can healthily lose 35 pounds in 3 months at your dimensions.  The ACSM (American College of Sports Medicine) categorizes healthy weight loss as 1-2 pounds per week.  Losing just 2 pounds per week equates to burning 7000 more calories than you consume during the week or 1000 every single day.  Continuing this for 3 months will have you losing 24 pounds.

You would probably be happy with losing 24 pounds in 3 months so you may as well get started.  The same generic exercise prescription can be given to anyone who wants to lose weight.  Start performing at least 20-30 minutes of continuous cardiovascular exercise 3-6 times per week.  Add 2-3 days of circuit weight training.  After the exercise begins to get easy, start making it more difficult on your self.  Of course you must eat a low to moderately caloric, healthy balanced diet while drinking plenty of water and you will be on your way.

Like you mentioned, if you went on a starvation diet or any other of those crazy fad diets (i.e. lemonade diet, no carb diet, etc.) there is a greater chance you would develop the side effects you mention but it would dramatically increase the chances of gaining the weight back and then some. 

Start off your program with the goal just to lose the first few pounds and establish a routine which you can maintain for the forseeable future.
You can see how long it will take to lose weight and/or tone up and how many calories you need to consume & burn in the fat loss matrix (calculators coming soon).

Comments (1)

Jan 26 / 7:00pm

Lose Weight While Improving Legs

QUESTION:

I am 45 yrs of age and trained many years with a wealth of knowledge when it comes to exercise. My problem is I want to increase leg size, this has always been a problem, crap legs runs in the family so I don't expect miracles. At the same time I need to lose approx 20-25lbs body fat which is proving to be a nightmare now that I am older. I do my weights, and then cardio on none weight training days, which includes bag work and jump rope amongst other things, but nothing changes.  My concern is that if I receive help with losing some body fat my legs will shrink to nothing, Can I lose some body fat and still improve my legs?

Exercises for my legs vary in order every 8 weeks, leg ext squat, leg press, leg curl, stiff leg dead lift & some times roman chair squat. Reps very 5X5 or 6-8 10-12 15-20 every 8 weeks and at present I train 3x week back-chest rest legs -shoulders rest biceps-triceps, after 8 weeks I will change to perhaps chest-biceps legs on there own rest shoulders-triceps, then back on its own and rest. There are many combinations I use each 8 week period and this always keeps things interesting. I have tried all sorts 10x10 gvt gironda 8x8 and 6x6 standard methods super sets and trisets. Many thanks for your time.

ANSWER:

It is definitely possible to maintain size in your muscles while you lose weight (fat).  There are a few reasons why people often lose a significant amount of muscle during a weight loss program.  Out of all the reasons the one you should be worried about is insufficient calorie/protein intake in relation to the amount of protein catabolism in the system. During weight loss there will be less anabolic hormones and available energy for reparation of muscles after training.

Just as you cannot eat the same way when trying to lose weight that you were eating when you were trying to put it on, you simply just cannot train the same way as when you were trying to build mass as you're dieting to lose weight.  Your lifting routine, specifically your leg routine sounds pretty comprehensive.  It is recommended you dramatically lower your weight training volume while you lower your caloric intake and increase your cardiovascular activity to burn.

Since weight training has become in vogue over the past 10 years people are beginning to get the wrong idea that weight training is the best thing for fat loss as well as building muscle.  Weight training is solely a stimulus for your body that depends completely on your diet.  If you weight train too much and don't consume enough calories it will have negative effects on your body including fatigue and loss of muscle mass.

Your goal with weight training is simply maintenance your current muscle mass.  You can minimize losing your leg mass by performing shorter duration workouts.  You do not need more than 3-6 sets of exercises for muscle group to maintain muscle.  In fact numerous studies have shown that a single set of weight training can be just as effective.  Including High Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) in your cardio program as opposed to mostly marathon style workouts will also help.  If you properly replenish your energy after HIIT workouts you are less likely to lose muscle mass as opposed to long duration workouts which are more likely to use your body protein as fuel.

Last but not least, your diet needs to stay balanced.  Eating 4-6 small meals per day, each containing adequate protein, carbohydrate and fat will help keep your insulin levels stable throughout the day.  You will be less likely to overeat, hindering your weight loss and you will be less likely to crash during a workout.  You may want to check out these combination exercises which will lessen your time in the weight room, work the full body quicker so you can concentrate on your calorie incinerating cardio.

Filed under  //  leg muscles   weight loss  

Comments (0)

Jan 26 / 5:20pm

Hard Time Catching Breath

QUESTION:

I have a heart rate monitor that I use when working out. My question is around my maximum target heart weight. I am 51 years old, approx. 25-30 pounds over my goal weight. My resting heart rate is around 90, as I begin to increse the speed on the treadmill it climbs to around 124-136 in a normal period of time.

My concern is that as I begin to run for a short period of time i.e. 1/2 mile (5 minutes) it jumps to the high 160's to low 170's! My legs are strong but I feel I need to quit running because my heart is beating so hard and I have a hard time catching my breath. Is this normal?

ANSWER:

First and Foremost:  Consult with your doctor and ask him/her whether this type of exercise is right for you (if you haven't already).  I have never been a fan of using heart rate charts for determining target heart rate.  Even if you use the Karvonen Formula which takes into account your resting heart rate, it still may not be right for you.

I recommend downloading and printing an RPE chart to take with you during exercise.  Remember the classic surgeon general's recommendations of 30 minutes of vigorous exercise 3 times per week or something to that effect?  The point is, heart rate is secondary to the effort you are putting in to your exercise, especially when you're a beginner or novice.

Try to exercise at a moderate intensity comparable to 4-6 on the RPE chart (above).  Take note of your heart rate as you try to maintain this intensity for at least 20 minutes.  Eventually you will be able increase your intensity and feel more comfortable at higher intensities (heart rates).  Once you begin to lose weight and improve your cardio fitness you will find that what currently exercise intensity makes it hard to catch your breath will be maintainable.

Comments (0)